User talk:Nano2014

Reply

Hi, thanks for message. Please add your messages to the bottom of the talk page, or they may be overlooked. I moved the article to its correct title and made these edits, some Manual of Style fixes, but most removing opinions, commentary and gushing non-neutral text like millions of admirers still long to see her perform... they dearly miss her cherished voice and the inspiration it has always exuded. This is an encyclopaedia article, not a fan page. Other comments

• Some of your references don't appear to work, please check. Also book references need a page number or numbers. Sources that are not acceptable include those linked to her, press releases, social media and other sites that can be her or her management. I'm not sure that all your sources meet those criteria. If you could improve the sources, that would be helpful. The 2014 deletion was because the deleting admin felt that the text didn't show that she met the notability criteria I've linked, basically saying that she was a singer who had retired and little else. My deletion, way back in 2007 was because the article was just a link
• It would greatly help to demonstrate her notability if you could find verifiable information on eg record sales, chart placings and the like. Do any of her albums have articles on this Wikipedia? If so, please link.
• External links should normally only be one to her own official page, no videos, social media or other sites.
• I'm not sure how relevant the "Further reading" is to her. It looks like general commentaries on Arab musical culture. I've left it for now, but you should consider whether it actually adds anything.

If you have any questions, please let me know. Jimfbleak - talk to me? 06:26, 13 July 2017 (UTC)

new update

I have added two photos and references. thanks --Nano2014 (talk) 03:24, 31 December 2019 (UTC)